Having drawn crowds since 1766, Cape May, New Jersey, is America’s oldest seaside resort. It’s no surprise that the town has developed a rich cuisine culture to match. From fresh-caught seafood to farm-to-table experiences, Cape May has lots to offer for casual diners and seasoned foodies alike. With Ocean Club Hotel, experience some of the best dining in Cape May and the surrounding area.
Ocean-Fresh Seafood
A trip to the shore isn’t complete without a seafood dining experience, and Cape May has plenty to offer. The Lobster House sits right on Fisherman’s Wharf with a gorgeous waterfront view. The restaurant runs its own fishing fleet, ensuring that all seafood served in its dining room and raw bar is fresh from the sea. It also runs an outdoor cocktail lounge on the deck of an authentic 130-foot-long schooner – a truly unique experience.
If you’re looking for a neighborhood atmosphere, try Oyster Bay Steak & Seafood. Just a few blocks away from Cape May Beach, this eatery offers clean and cozy décor with a nautical twist. Its menu includes steak, seafood, salads, and other classic fare, so there’s something here for everyone.
Farm-to-Table Dining
“Farm-to-table” is a hot dining trend that prioritizes locally sourced, organic ingredients from independent farms. This style is both delicious and sustainable, and it allows restaurant owners to highlight regional products.
The Ebbitt Room is one of Cape May’s premier farm-to-table experiences. Its innovative dishes use fresh produce from Beach Plum Farm, supplemented by an award-winning wine list of over 90 selections. Situated inside a renovated 1879 hotel, it offers a gorgeous upscale environment.
For a more rustic vibe, you can also visit Beach Plum Farm itself. These dinners celebrate the seasonal harvest and can be enjoyed under the stars or in the quaint hoop house.
Keeping it Casual
Are you looking for a more casual experience? Cape May also offers some easy eating that won’t require you to take off your vacation gear. Here are some of our hits:
- Mad Batter: A popular local brunch spot, this long-standing Cape May establishment offers a full-menu breakfast and lunch and an eclectic dinner selection.
- Rusty Nail: This iconic establishment delivers the full beach bar experience, complete with a wood bar, live entertainment, and tables right on the sand.
- Mayer’s Tavern: Formerly billed as one of the best dive bars in America, Mayer’s Tavern rebranded in 2018 with a delicious pub menu and a party boat atmosphere.
The town also features several pizzerias, cafes, and sandwich shops, making it easy to grab a bite to go.
Satisfying Your Sweet Tooth
All this delicious dining may leave you with a hankering for dessert. Louisa’s is known for its excellent desserts. It also runs a chocolate bar next door, which offers artisan chocolates and caramels – perfect for snacking or for gifts to take home. Or, stop by The Magnolia Room for mouthwatering Southern classics such as blueberry cobbler and lemon meringue pie. Other sweet treats around town include cupcakes, homemade fudge, and ice cream by the scoop.
Explore the Best Dining in Cape May with Ocean Club Hotel
Finally, you can stay true to the vacation spirit by eating where you stay. Ocean Club Hotel is home to the SeaSalt Restaurant, beachfront fine dining without the fuss. We also offer stylish modern accommodations with beachfront views, balconies, cabana rooms, and more, providing premier comfort while you explore the best dining Cape May, NJ, has to offer. Book now to reserve your stay.